Kara Swisher

Recent Posts by Kara Swisher

Death to the Preroll? One Can Dream.

Well, it is about time, I’d say.

youtube

That would be that ads will start to be put into YouTube videos rather than nearby on the site. Called InVideo ads, they will be semi-see-through “overlays” that will go over part of professionally made content (and in some user-generated videos).

There will, of course, be ad-revenue sharing with partners, although it is not clear if enough professional content is on YouTube yet to make a giant business.

It is not a particularly innovative move on the part of Google, which bought YouTube for $1.65 billion last year and also bought a lot of copyright-infringement trouble, too. Several other online video companies like VideoEgg have been trying out similar solutions recently.

But Google’s move will obviously have reverberations, as YouTube is the most popular online video destination, with users who spend a lot of time on the site. Google is already dominant in the online search-ad market and can easily move markets to change past practices in new arenas.

That might include killing off the horrid reliance on prerolls, 15-second ads that precede a video that most consumers despise.

moneypit

And, for that alone, we salute Google, VideoEgg and anyone else who can come up with different video ad solutions that work. Until then, the explosion of online video–which is the really key trend on the Web now–could become the most popular application and also the biggest money pit.

Now that the video ads are rolling, I am sure the same content providers YouTube is trying to make ad revenues with might look forward to that supposed “fingerprinting” technology designed to thwart copyright infringement on sites like, well, YouTube.

Please see this disclosure related to me and Google (owner of YouTube).


comments so far. Add yours.

  • http://allthingsd.com/ Edward Thomas

    There’s been a lot of discussion of how to value hot online video properties, like YouTube. There of course are many factors to this, but I propose a simple valuation model by using common web metrics to gauge user engagement. In other words, a simple way to value an online video property is in terms of not only how big its audience is but also how engaged they are (similar to a TV show). The more attention we have, the higher the prospects are for gaining advertisement revenue, and therefore the more valuable the property is.

    Using this model we can also gauge what other online video sites might be worth by comparing user engagement relative to that of YouTube.

    To read more, go here:
    http://www.edwardjthomas.org/?p=10

  • http://allthingsd.com/ Corey Kronengold

    Kara-

    The broader question, which I raised yesterday on my blog, http://www.OnlineVideoWatch.com , is what types of content should be monetized at all.

    Long form, high quality, professionally produced content very well supports the pre- roll format.

    All online video is not created equal, however it is generally discussed that way. Certainly no user-generated content that is 30 seconds long should have a :15 or :30 second pre-roll. However, content of 2-5 minutes of length certainly does.

    The conversation needs to move beyond “pre-roll is bad.” Pre-roll is not a bad format. Pre-roll is a bad format for YouTube. Does anyone really need to see advertising of any kind on videos of a guy getting hit in the groin with a baseball?

    HP recently ran a campaign using the VideoEgg layovers that included videos of insurgents blowing themselves up. Should there be advertising on that type of content?

    Lets look at the broader issues of advertising on online video and not label pre-roll as a bad format when the problem is when and where it is used, not with the format itself. http://www.onlinevideowatch.co.....-covenant/

  • http://petesview.net Peter Childs

    It symplistic to think that there should be a relationship between the length of the pre-roll and the length of the video. It’s psycho-economics that matter. It the video is precieved to have enough value people will sit through a pre-roll. Of course that means that pre-roll can only be added after the video has established some currency.

    The biggest argument against pre-rolls is that they don’t play well with embedding – and that’s the key to web distribution.

    BTW you should let people with blogs include their blog address in the signature of their comment.

  • http://petesview.net Peter Childs

    Opps – I retract my final comment – If you change the blog address from the default “All Things Digital” (as I did) there is a link to the commenters blog in the signature.

Dive Into Media

Latest Video

View all videos »

Search »

One thing that we have learned is that piracy is not a pricing issue. It’s a service issue. The easiest way to stop piracy is not by putting antipiracy technology to work. It’s by giving those people a service that’s better than what they’re receiving from the pirates.

— Gabe Newell, co-founder of videogame company Valve, which publishes Portal and Half-Life