Not Showing at Netflix: The Great Online Ad Slowdown
That odd bit of cognitive dissonance surfaced yesterday, when the DVD rental company said it hadn’t been able to buy Web ads at a discount at the end of 2008. Hard to tell if it’s meaningful–does this mean the slowdown hasn’t been as great as people think, or is it just a statistical anomaly?–but it is interesting.
The details: During the company’s Q4 earnings call, CEO Reed Hastings told analysts that Netflix “didn’t see any benefits” from lower online ad pricing during the last three months of last year.
That’s odd, since Netflix (NFLX) buys more online ad inventory than just about everyone. Last year, when Nielsen Online was providing monthly reports about top advertisers on the Web, Netflix routinely made the Top 10 list, along with a handful or mortgage and finance companies. (Surely you’ve been annoyed by the company’s omnipresent pop-under ads). So if anything, its leverage should have increased in the past few months.
That prompted a follow-up question along those lines. Transcript via Seeking Alpha:
Youssef Squali–Jefferies & Co.
Barry, just a quick clarification, I think you said in your answer to a question that was posed before that you have not seen any benefit from lower ad rates in Q4. I’m just trying to reconcile that. Everything that we’re hearing from ad players out there, online ad players that at least on the CPM side and particularly on non-premium inventory where you guys seem to spend a lot of money, we’ve seen double digit declines year-on-year. Given the fact that you’re one of the top 20 online advertisers out there how can you not see a benefit?
Netflix CFO Barry McCarthy
You know, I put the question to our chief marketing officer in almost exactly the same tone and he reminded me that we already buy at low rates in mostly the remnant market so what must be happening is that the trickle down affect hasn’t yet hit the remnants space which is already incredibly discounted.”
It’d be great to think that remnant space–the cheap inventory Web sites usually hand over to ad networks or Google (GOOG) when they can’t sell it on their own–hasn’t come down significantly, but that’s not what I hear anecdotally, and that’s not what a barrage of reports has indicated.
The graph below, for instance, comes from ad optimization company PubMatic, which just reported “dramatic” drops in pricing over the last year. We’re likely to hear more of the same from Yahoo (YHOO) today. Anyone want to explain why Netflix hasn’t seen a benefit from those fire sales?