Peter Kafka

Recent Posts by Peter Kafka

LimeWire Gives Up the Ghost, Shuts Down P2P File-Sharing Client

Last spring, music file-sharing service LimeWire suffered a crushing blow in federal court. This is the net result: The company is shutting down its core software–though it insists it’s not doing that exactly. It’s the victory the big music labels have been seeking for some time.

The company says it will comply with a court injunction to turn off “the searching, downloading, uploading, file trading and/or file distribution functionality, and/or all functionality” of its software, which remains one of the most popular methods of finding free–and illegal–music on the Web.

That means the company will stop offering downloads of its software, which you could still get on its site as of late Tuesday afternoon. And it also means that the company will disable the software that’s already been downloaded, according to people familiar with LimeWire’s plans.

I don’t know if LimeWire intends to cripple its client via a “kill switch” or some other method, but as of 20 minutes ago it hadn’t gone into effect–I was able to locate and download a version of the Clash’s “I Fought the Law” within a minute of booting up LimeWire’s software. (UPDATE for the technically minded, via a person familiar with the company’s plans: “They’ve taken down the relay severs on the Gnutella network which the Limewire client uses to figure out which other p2p clients have what info on them.” This should render existing clients effectively useless as anything other than a media player within the next nine hours, I’m told.)

LimeWire‘s client has been downloaded “hundreds of millions” of times, and is still responsible for the “vast majority” of usage on the Gnutella trading network, says Eric Garland, who runs the BigChampagne media tracking service. The company’s moves won’t affect other open source clients that run on the same Gnutella network, like FrostWire.

Meanwhile, LimeWire’s parent company, Lime Group, is prepping a new music service that it says will be legal, and should be due out in a month.

But the utility of that service depends on the participation of the big music labels, and at least for now the labels are still trying to extract a big piece of Lime Group’s hide. Court hearings in the damages phase of Lime Group’s hire are scheduled to resume in January. And this statement by industry trade group RIAA makes it clear that the labels aren’t feeling conciliatory:

“For the better part of the last decade, Limewire and Gorton have violated the law. The court has now signed an injunction that will start to unwind the massive piracy machine that Limewire and Gorton used to enrich themselves immensely. In January, the court will conduct a trial to determine the appropriate level of damages necessary to compensate the record companies for the billions and billions of illegal downloads that occurred through the Limewire system.”

Today’s announcement comes after Lime and the labels spent weeks trying to negotiate an out-of-court settlement; Federal District Court judge Kimba Wood actually handed down the injunction in August.

Here’s LimeWire CEO George Searle’s description of events, via  blog post:

As of today, we are required to stop distribution and support of LimeWire’s P2P file-sharing service as a result of a court-ordered injunction.

Naturally, we’re disappointed with this turn of events. We are extremely proud of our pioneering history and have, for years, worked hard to bridge the gap between technology and content rights holders. However, at this time, we have no option but to cease further distribution and support of our software.

It’s a sad occasion for our team, and for you–the hundreds of millions of people who have used LimeWire to discover new things.

While we have enabled open sharing and discovery for the past decade, LimeWire is mostly the product of the people who used it. You made LimeWire. Thank you for letting us being part of that. Your support and enthusiasm has fueled everything that we do.

During this challenging time, we are excited about the future. The injunction applies only to the LimeWire product. Our company remains open for business.

We remain deeply committed to working with the music industry and making the act of loving music more fulfilling for everyone – including artists, songwriters, publishers, labels, and of course music fans.Our team of technologists and music enthusiasts are creating a completely new music service that puts you back at the center of your digital music experience.

We’ll be sharing more details about our new service and look forward to bringing it to you in the future.

And here’s a LimeWire PR rep’s description of what’s going on:

As a result of a court ordered injunction, we are required to disable “the searching, downloading, uploading, file trading and/or file distribution functionality, and/or all functionality” of LimeWire’s P2P file-sharing software.

Please note LimeWire’s official statement on this legal development is as follows:

“While this is not our ideal path, we hope to work with the music industry in moving forward.  We look forward to embracing necessary changes and collaborating with the entire music industry in the future.”  – LimeWire Spokesperson.

An important point of clarification, LimeWire is not “shutting down”, in specific regarding our software, we are compelled to use our best efforts cease support and distribution of the file-sharing software, along with increased filtering.  And, that is what we are doing.


Latest Video

View all videos »

Search »

I think the NSA has a job to do and we need the NSA. But as (physicist) Robert Oppenheimer said, “When you see something that is technically sweet, you go ahead and do it and argue about what to do about it only after you’ve had your technical success. That is the way it was with the atomic bomb.”

— Phil Zimmerman, PGP inventor and Silent Circle co-founder, in an interview with Om Malik