John Paczkowski

Recent Posts by John Paczkowski

Sirius Stiffs Stern; Stern Sues Sirius

howard-stern-fistLast December Howard Stern quelled concerns that he might leave SiriusXM Radio by signing a new five-year contract. Now, just three months later, he’s suing the new company, claiming it bilked him out of the performance-based stock awards promised to him by the old one.

“When Sirius needed Stern, it promised him a share in any success that the company achieved,” the suit reads. “But now that Sirius has conquered its chief competitor and acquired more than 20 million subscribers, it has reneged on its commitment to Stern, unilaterally deciding that it has paid him enough.”

According to the suit, Sirius did give Stern his initial stock award after he signed on in January 2006, but it failed to pay him out on any others even though it “exceeded its own internal estimates by more than 2 million subscribers” each year for the remainder of the original contract.

“Stern enabled Sirius to surpass its internal subscriber targets by more than 2 million subscribers in 2006 and in 2007,” the suit alleges. “Because of this success and the revenue that it brought into the company, [Stern] was entitled to receive the performance-based stock awards Sirius promised [him].”

So Sirius is stiffing Stern. Not a particularly wise move given the latter’s irascibility and reach of his daily radio show. If there’s a PR battle to be fought here, Sirius will likely lose it first thing tomorrow morning when Stern’s back on the air again.

Reached for comment, Sirius claimed to have met its obligations to Stern. “SIRIUS XM just signed a contract through 2015 with Howard Stern, and he is a valued part of our company,” spokesman Patrick Reilly told me. “We were thus surprised and disappointed by the subsequent legal action initiated by his production company and agent. We have met all of our obligations under the terms of our 2004 agreement with Howard, his agent and production company.”

Here’s a copy of the suit:


SternSuit


comments so far. Add yours.

  • http://www.youtube.com/user/califmerchant#p/a/u/2/mS3zDLE_19s califmerchant

    hm can u really sue ur employer while u still workin for them?

  • Anonymous

    Why has Howard waited this long to sue? He just signed new contract 3 months ago; you’d think this issue (if real) would have been resolved during new contract negotiations. Something fishy here. Has Howard change his mind about working another 5 years? I have no clue, but this latest ‘news’ doesn’t feel like the real issue here. JMHO. Your article is not balanced at all or worse…

  • Anonymous

    Very curious to hear your theory of what the “real issue” is here, because looking over the 20+ page lawsuit included above Stern’s position seems pretty clear cut to me–even if he is making it after re-upping his contract.

  • Anonymous

    Thanks for providing a copy of the law suit. Very gracious of you. I am long SIRI (if 5000 shares is considered long in this stock). I read the above law suit. All the allegations may be true, but it still doesn’t answer why One Twelve and Buchwald didn’t insist on resolving this before they signed a new deal. My conspiracy side is now kicking in: Did One Twelve and Buchwald agree to 3 months ‘silence’ until the latest earnings came out? If so, I’ve got a real shareholder issue for Sirius/XM to consider. As I initially wondered, has Howard changed his mind? Is something else going on here behind this law suit? Lots of the ‘facts’ are in the deal actually signed 5 years ago and recently, but I have no clue what those deals actually say.

  • Anonymous

    Why didn’t he bring it up at contract negotiations? It wasn’t in his interest. Sirius probably figured that he didn’t realize that he had been underpaid. He did, but didn’t want to let them know that he knew, because if they had to pay the bonus, they would have wanted to pay less for the next five years. Therefore, he signs the 5 year contract now, and sues for the money they owe him later, after the deal is locked up.

Latest Video

View all videos »

Search »

I break down a product the same way I break down a character I’m going to play. I try to get inside the mind of that person — the user, the consumer — and figure out why they’re doing something and what they want from it.

— Ashton Kutcher’s investing philosophy