John Paczkowski

Recent Posts by John Paczkowski

Actually, Amateur Hour Seems Far From Over, RIM

“Amateur hour is over.”

That’s the slogan Research in Motion is using to promote its new BlackBerry PlayBook tablet. But with skepticism for the company’s prospects on the rise, that proclamation is becoming increasingly more ironic. To wit, the growing mound of analyst downgrades piling around the company like manure on a horse farm. Seems nobody is much buying RIM’s exuberant guidance for full-year profits of $7.50 per share, particularly after its recent profit warning and a disappointing BlackBerry World developers conference.

On Wednesday, Societe Generale analyst Andy Perkins downgraded RIM to Hold from Buy, lowered his price target on its shares to $50 from $70 and trimmed his EPS estimates on the company for the next two years.

“We have seen time and again in the mobile manufacturing business that a ‘one-off’ poor quarter can lead to a whole series of others,” Perkins explained in a note to clients. “So while we note management’s full year guidance, we are very cautious about building this into our base case. We had hoped that the extremely successful international operations would give RIM time to introduce its new models into the U.S. market. However, these models have been delayed and will not have the new QNX operating system when they are finally launched. As such, we believe RIM is likely to struggle for much of the remainder of the year.”

Bleak, though perhaps not quite as bad as it sounds.

Perkins says RIM’s profit warning isn’t a disaster. At its mid-range guidance, the company’s sales would be up 28 percent year over year and its EPS flat.


comments so far. Add yours.

  • Anonymous

    Amateur hour was over when Apple launched the iPad in 2010.

    It got a second wind with Galaxy & Xoom. This second wind was downgraded to a Zephyr at the launch of Playbook.

    Ayuh

  • http://twitter.com/chrispycrunch Chris Lau

    Ask iPad owners if they carry their device around. Most I ask leave them at home. The limitation (and it strength) is that it’s like a computer…too heavy to hold and carry for long periods of time.

    The Playbook is actually portable and powerful. It’s nowhere near mainstream so it will take at least 2-3 quarters for sales to be significant. Until then, RIM needs to keep building and launching usable apps. You know, the 1% apps that 99% use…not the 99% of apps that no one uses (except for companies using that figure as a merit of their app store).

  • John Peters

    What a ridiculous title to the article that has nothing to do with the actual article itself. John, have you even bothered to use a PlayBook lately? The Amateur Hour Is Over title refers to the PlayBook and it’s absolutely accurate. I bought my device two weeks ago and it’s simply amazing. Super fast, incredible audio and video, more apps than I need (even a Facebook app that the iPad doesn’t have), a web browser that is best in its field, and the full version of Documents To Go. Unless you’re deep in Apple distortion field, you would also believe that amateur time is over.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=647483063 Xavier Yaffar

    And most people I ask carry their iPads with them so where does that leave us? Anecdotal data is next to worthless.

    Come back when you do serious research.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_4HUNCTTMESNI4FGSUTCSVQ765I r20mm2m

    rim has always been a tug over between long and short analysts often long analysts loose faith and switch over to the short side. rim is bottoming out the bad news has been factored in/ the stock has already been downgraded numerous times- basille already aired out the negatives and that’s it- their not going out of busiess – however the stock does need a catalyst jun 29 report coming up and with all the products in the pipe line rim will have the numbers dont let the analysts fool u = the playook is a beautiful product and will do well

  • http://www.facebook.com/MACricio Mauricio Villarreal Camacho

    I see more of a ¨RIM Distortion field¨ than an Apple one, of course if you are a RIM user & your needs are limited then the playbook would be perfect for you, on the other hand there are the million of other people who doesn’t find it capable enough.

  • http://profiles.google.com/pfezziwig Charlie Fezziwig

    Seems the more money RIMM makes the less their stock is valued. Maybe they should try selling fewer phones and making less money in an effort to improve their stock value with intelligent investors?

    Are there any Apple fanatics out there seriously believing an iTab and iPhone are Enterprise Level devices?

  • Anonymous

    It also depends who you ask and what age group.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_BQAKT4CAIOQ4AOBGY3MS3GANMM J-Credible

    That’s doubtful. iPad owners typically have an iPhone which they carry around instead. The iPhone4 is a much MUCH better device spec-wise than the iPad is. iPad is great for sitting in the couch to find some quick info, but not much else. Playbook is more of a ‘companion’ to the Blackberry phone rather than a mirror-device at a larger size. I will be honest in public I see far more Samsung Tab’s and Playbook’s out there right now. Not because the devices are superior, but because they’re mobile. The iPad is not a mobile device, it it however a portable device. Apparently I’m not the only person who has come to this conclusion as Mark Zuckerberg did mention last year the reason why there is no official Facebook app for the iPad and why it is not being discussed at the mobile conference is because the iPad is not a mobile device. He has however commited (and delivered) a mobile Facebook app for Playbook.

    I don’t think that means much to the consumer, they will purchase the device that best suits their needs. Some people want a device for using on the road, others want a netbook for home use.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_BQAKT4CAIOQ4AOBGY3MS3GANMM J-Credible

    I agree. Playbook is great for the 60 million existing Blackberry users, or even the other (unknown) millions of Android users (like myself). I don’t have an iPhone, I am very happy with my Android device though. I did have an original iPad after it was released and promptly sold it—at the time the ecosystem just wasn’t developed as it is now, and didn’t suit my needs. The playbook does seem to be a compelling device to fit in my life with my Android phone though.

  • http://www.facebook.com/MACricio Mauricio Villarreal Camacho

    I´m sure there are Apple Fanatics as you say, but those are not important, the businesses who are actively seeking to integrate the iPad, iPod Touch & iPhone on his ecosystem are the ones Apple is negotiating with.

  • http://www.facebook.com/anthony.heslehurst Anthony Daniel Heslehurst

    I don’t care what the analysts are speculating.
    I’ll be buying a Playbook the second it arrives in the UK. Its the best new tablet on the market, simple as that. I’m even considering switching my phone to a blackberry.

    Last time I checked, the first weekend sales of the Playbook in the US smashed sales of all Android competitors. The Playbook is selling thousands more than the Xoom or the Galaxy Tab, despite the over-negative analysts and US reviews.

    Anyone who things this market is sewn up already needs a reality check. Its still very early days, and the Playbook is off to an impressive start.

  • http://twitter.com/CoreyHodder Corey Hodder

    I bought a playbook during launch week. i have not regretted it once. It is a very strong device that i tend take everywhere with me.
    i have used the ipad and ipad2, neither of which i enjoyed enough to consider purchasing. 100 Fart Apps are not my style.

  • http://twitter.com/mccannic mccannic

    That is complete nonsense and you know it. I see iPads everywhere and carry my own with virtually everywhere I go. I have four friends with iPads and we even take it to the pub for the MLB app during baseball games. Find a real point to make rather than make things up.

  • Anonymous

    I’ve been using one on and off once since it launched. My experience and impressions of the device are very different from yours.

  • http://www.facebook.com/tongejonathan Jonathan Tonge

    I LOVE PLAYBOOK.

    QNX is hands down the best operating system. The speed and the PlayBook’s ability to multitask. Not only that, but QNX is linux based, which should be a developers wet dream. PlayBook literally blows my mind.

    The US media and apple fanboys aren’t going to change their mind, even in the face of much better devices.

  • Anonymous

    It’s funny because when I show regular people a PlayBook and how well it functions they are wow-ed because they’re so used to how primitive iOS is. Ie: grid of icons, home button to exit. Rinse and repeat. If more people actually tried the PlayBook in person and had the brains to know how to operate it, they would realize how amatuer iOS is as a tablet OS.

  • Anonymous

    Have you used a Zoom or IPad for surfing the net? Zoom is just garbage for browsing the web (At lease the version I used)… so now everyone is praying that Android 3.1 will fix this, and as for safari for the IPad, that too is also garbage (that why I didn’t buy Ipad2)… and you have 300k apps to replace that browser. I’m not say that platform is garbage, but they have a lot of work to do with there browser to catchup to the playbook, and the playbook has a lot of work to do to catch up on the apps front. No platform is perfect, but since getting the playbook, I’ve stopped using my netbook for anything, but I still use my desktop.

    So your say that even worse case situation for RIM that they will grow at %28 and make %5.99 profit and they still deserve the 6.5 multiple? And even looking out at 2013, they are still growing, while other companies…. nokia (12.5 X earns, and Moto 30 X earns) are losing mark share fast then RIM and have higher multiples. And now these companies are in the hardware trap… race to the cheapest best hardware… Nokia is really there with 9 or 10 percent margins and hope Window mobile 7 will get them out… Fat chance as MS will sell WM7 to anybody. Well at lease they have Navtaq.

    Business don’t change over night, and it will take just a few real security scares, like viruses on Android or something to wake people up that you need to protect your data. Notice RIM is not in front of congress?

  • Anonymous

    QNX is an amazing operating system. That alone, however, isn’t going to guarantee the success of the Playbook. Perhaps only old timers understand that “the best” doesn’t always translate into “the winner”. Best is defined by a multitude of market variables, not hardware or software specs. For better or worse, the iPad is the leader.

    Furthermore, RIMs crippling of the Playbook’s abilities with Blackberry Bridge are abhorrent and will hind the tablet’s success.

  • Anonymous

    There needs to be a survey done on this subject matter.  I just keep reading speculative information about the iPad use.  In addition, on that survey, a question should be asked would you prefer to have Adobe flash on the iPad.  I would love to hear the voice of the customer instead of the voice of Steve Jobs.  The customers requirements and expectations are typically are what are important, not the company/CEO requirements….I am very surprised how well the iPhone has done being that it is a defective product due to the antenna issue, which has never been fixed.  Steve Jobs told his customers not to hold the phone a certain way – none issue.  His customers followed his command by doing what he told them to do… He should change his name from Steve Jobs to Jim Jones because his followers are willing to drink his “kool-aid”……

  • Chris

    iOS is also Unix based. Your point?

  • Anonymous

    Playbook been great for me… better then my Ipad1 and way better then the Zoom I had for 2 days. (Zoom OS is garbage)

    Had some issues with build 1690 with apps closing, but that was fixed in 1710. Love the design, and yes the IOS seems dated compared to the Playbook which is by far the best GUI out there.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1200030562 Doug Broussard

    Good luck with that. I think you misplaced the “fanboy” in your post, though.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1200030562 Doug Broussard

    Yes, what a wonderful world it would be if everyone was as smart as you. Meanwhile, millions get work done on iPads and that stupid grid of icons while PlayBook’s genius is left to rot unappreciated. Maybe that’s because Genius doesn’t have a BB phone and can’t browse the web with the PlayBook.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1200030562 Doug Broussard

    Please keep us informed on the daily build/bug/update schedule and let us know when the product is ready to ship to people who are buying iPads.

  • Anonymous

    Hahaha, you are a perfect example of how delusional and uneducated iPad users can be. First off, the wifi PB, has the same connectivity as wifi iPad. Saying you need a BB to connect is like saying an iPad needs an iPhone to connect.. false. Secondly, ever heard of something called tethering? PB supports BB, iPhone, Android tethering. You do not specifically need a BB to access the web. Thirdly, the browsing experience on the PB easily trumps the iPad. It has Flash and more HTML5 support than the iPad. Fourthly, go around asking iPad owners what they use their iPad for.. most will say browsing the web, watching movies, playing games, so don’t give me that getting work done BS.

  • Anonymous

    And Apple IOS never released anything buggy?  btw, hows version 4.3.3 of IOS… oh wait you can reply because it’s causing wifi problem… better luck with version 4.3.4.

     let me know how’s the debug going

Latest Video

View all videos »

Search »

Twitter’s still in its honeymoon period, but that won’t last forever. At some point, it’s going to be less of a wunderkammer, and more of a regrettable necessity.

— Reuters finance blogger Felix Salmon, in an article entitled “Why Twitter will get more annoying”