John Paczkowski

Recent Posts by John Paczkowski

Analyst: Early Android Tablet Entries Can't Compete With iPad

“If you were to ask me in two years’ time, will Apple have less than 50 percent of the global tablet market, I think that’s a certainty.”

Neil Mawston, Strategy Analytics, January 2011

The iPad’s dominance of the market for tablet computers may not prove as short-lived as some analysts have predicted. Though beset by a proliferation of new rivals, particularly those based on Google’s Android operating system, the company’s share of this fast-growing market isn’t eroding nearly as quickly as expected.

Why? According to Jeffries analyst Peter Misek, Android tablets simply aren’t competitive. “We have thus far been very disappointed with nearly every Android-based tablet,” said Misek–so disappointed that he’s slashed his 2011 tablet forecast to 70 million units from 100 million. In his opinion, Android tablets won’t come close to rivaling the iPad until their OS is more refined and their prices come down.

“[Android] Honeycomb is an OS that seems rushed and still requires significant polishing,” Misek says. “Our own multiple-week interaction with Honeycomb tablets showed daily crashes, bugs, and program hangs. Yet our iPad has yet to experience any of these trends or idiosyncrasies.”

And beyond this, Android tablets are simply too expensive.

“We believe there is significant price elasticity in the market, and these additional tablets have all in our view failed in one key category: providing a compelling discount to the iPad,” he explains, adding that Android tablet OEMs must cut prices if they’re ever to establish a beachhead against Apple’s tablet.

Eventually, says Misek, Android tablets will be quite competitive with iOS tablets, but not until these issues are addressed. Until then, the iPad will continue to dominate.


comments so far. Add yours.

  • http://twitter.com/slowbutlearning Billy Joe

    Jeffries analyst Peter Misek This guy is so full of BS.
    out of all the 45 some analyst he has poor research skills 
    Just look at Amazon or best buy or office max sales and comments Motorola’s Xoom tablet has been in the top slot since release and has 3 time the reviews as the Ipad and Ipad2 with much better reviews than the Ipad2.
    Look for yourself There are over 400 used and new any color or spec. Ipad and Ipad2 for sale at less than retail yes less than retail.
    Peter M. is a payed shill with poor skills as and analyst.
    Just this morning Foxconn reported 70% of there tablet and smart phone sales are to NOk and MMI and there unit production  will increase from 55mil units last yr. to 97.5 unit for 2011Foxcomm sees dramatic improvement in 2011Wed May 18, 2011 6:25am EDT

  • Anonymous

    You know,
    after all the millions of cell phones that have been sold, you still can’t buy one out right for less than 500 or $600. Why do you think a tablet which is more expensive to manufacture should or could be any cheaper?

    If Android tablets can come down to $200.00, I doubt I would want one.

  • http://twitter.com/slowbutlearning Billy Joe

     That’s a strong argument Seem going to Amazon to prove to yourself how weak ipads are doing would be out of the question and reading the poor review would be over the top.

  • Anonymous

    Come on back to reality. No one is buying that crap.
    It’s not a tablet market, its an iPad market. Get over it.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_HETNHROJD35LMNYNPPBTD6S6NU J

    The last review I saw on Android tablets (may have even been an ATD review) was that they constantly freeze up in different apps, the OS is unfinished, and they are just not ready for general consumers.  I am sure Google will improve their copy job of Apple’s iOS, but until they can match the user experience and until they can gain a price advantage over the iPad, then they will not sell as well as the iPad. 

  • Anonymous

    The only reason iPad is not at #1 on Amazon’s best selling tablets list is because there are many iPad models. The 16GB iPad is counted separately from the 32GB model. That is why 10 of the top 20 tablets are iPads. So iPad is actually outselling all the other tablets on Amazon, even with the fact that 3rd party retailers like Amazon are getting short supply, even with the fact that Amazon is pushing Android at every turn, even with Amazon’s nerdy audience.

  • Anonymous

    The non-Apple tablets are all Linux-on-the-desktop. There are too many pieces missing for consumer use. Android v3 does not even have support for C apps, which is 99% of PC apps, and Android v3′s HTML5 support is surprisingly broken, meaning it can’t run most Web apps correctly.

    So you pay just as much or more than iPad to get your Android hardware, but there is almost no software, and there won’t be anything other than baby Java apps unless Google opens up the native C API on Android, which is currently only used by Google engineers.

    Linux-on-the-desktop is actually more useful than Android tablets, because at least with Linux you have a C API and the Apache Web server and advanced scripting with PHP, Python, Perl, and so on. So Android v3 is literally less PC than Ubuntu. Google is out of their minds. Just way, way off. They are suffering from a kind of nerd myopia that was inexcusable even in the 90′s but is just indescribably foolish today.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Sashank-Mouli/1091566909 Sashank Mouli

     when i first read ipad and tablet . i thought this doesnt require further reading .

    a big FAIL article . ipad is not a tablet

  • http://twitter.com/slowbutlearning Billy Joe

    Jeffries analyst Peter Misek This guy is so full of BS.

    out of all the 45 some analyst he has poor research skills 

    Just look at Amazon or best buy or office max sales and comments
    Motorola’s Xoom tablet has been in the top slot since release and has 3
    time the reviews as the Ipad and Ipad2 with much better reviews than the
    Ipad2.

    Look for yourself There are over 400 used and new any color or spec.
    Ipad and Ipad2 for sale at less than retail yes less than retail.

    Peter M. is a payed shill with poor skills as and analyst.

    Just this morning Foxconn reported 70% of there tablet and smart phone
    sales are to NOk and MMI and there unit production  will increase from
    55mil units last yr. to 97.5 unit for 2011
    Foxcomm sees dramatic improvement in 2011Wed May 18, 2011 6:25am EDT

  • Anonymous

    Foxconn is making different types of products for Motorola and MMI and Nokia. Foxconn is NOT just making mobile phones and NOT just make high-end smartphones. 

    Motorola has two parts and both sell electronics. Motorola proper sells everything from bar code scanner to two-way radios to mobile computers to modem. 

    MMI deals with mobile phones and tablet devices. 

    Nokia offers 22 models of phones in US alone. Nokia is the world’s largest seller of mobile phones. 

    The simplistic comparison does not work. 

  • Anonymous

    Actually Apple simply doesn’t sell the iPad via Amazon — only scalpers do.

Latest Video

View all videos »

Search »

Twitter’s still in its honeymoon period, but that won’t last forever. At some point, it’s going to be less of a wunderkammer, and more of a regrettable necessity.

— Reuters finance blogger Felix Salmon, in an article entitled “Why Twitter will get more annoying”