Peter Kafka

Recent Posts by Peter Kafka

If Netflix Were on TV, It Might Be the Biggest Network on Cable. But About That New Show …

hemlock-groveGood news for Netflix! The company streamed more than 4 billion hours of video in the first three months of the year, according to a Facebook post from CEO Reed Hastings.*

BTIG analyst Rich Greenfield crunches those numbers (registration required), and concludes that this makes Netflix the equivalent of the most-watched cable TV network: He figures there are 28 million U.S. Netflix subscribers watching an average of 87 minutes of Netflix per day, or 43 hours per month. That puts it on par with the Disney Channel.

Presumably some of those hours were spent watching “House of Cards,” Netflix’s first big-budget foray into original programming. Which leads us to the maybe-not-such-good-news for Netflix: Its next show may be a dud.

You can’t say the reviews are in for “Hemlock Grove,” a horror series from director Eli Roth that debuts next week. But one prominent review is in, from the Hollywood Reporter’s Tim Goodman.

And it is not good at all.

“Here comes the company’s first truly bad series,” Goodman writes, then goes on to complain about the show’s writing, acting, casting and everything else.

Even people who are really, really high may not be satisfied with this one, Goodman says: “Is there a bong big enough for this show?”

If you want to spin this positively on Netflix’s behalf, you can point out that this is a single review. [UPDATE: An eagle-eyed tipster directs me to a much more positive review from People magazine, which gives the show three out of four stars: "Imagine "True Blood" directed by Sofia Coppola". You can see a screenshot of the review below.]

And if you want to keep going, you can argue that there are lots of popular TV shows that critics don’t like (though no one was making this argument when “House of Cards” got raves).

Want more? Okay. Even if “Hemlock Grove” is a real stinker, Netflix gets more chances, just like any other TV network. A new season of “Arrested Development,” up next month, is almost certain to succeed, based on the show’s rabid fan base, much of which was cultivated on Netflix in the first place.

* Don’t worry! The SEC has now blessed this form of communication, which is a good thing, since it’s 2013. Phew.

Here’s that People review:

people hemlock grove review


Latest Video

View all videos »

Search »

There was a worry before I started this that I was going to burn every bridge I had. But I realize now that there are some bridges that are worth burning.

— Valleywag editor Sam Biddle