Apple: It’s Time to Close the Book on DOJ’s E-Book Case
The U.S. Department of Justice’s e-book price fixing case against Apple wrapped up Thursday with largely predictable closing arguments from Cupertino and the government both.
Summarizing Apple’s defense against the DOJ’s allegations of price-fixing and conspiracy, lead counsel Orin Snyder argued that the agency not only failed to meet its burden of proof, but overreached by seeking to prosecute Apple for legitimate business practices.
“Apple did not conspire with a single publisher to fix prices in the e-book industry,” Snyder said, arguing that the negotiations under scrutiny in this case were nothing more than “standard, lawful business activity.” And the DOJ’s claim that they were more than that, a nefarious plot over which Apple served as ringmaster, is entirely unsupported. “All of the government’s evidence is ambiguous at best,” Snyder argued, lambasting the DOJ’s case as one built on “word games and inferences.”
Apple didn’t force Amazon or anyone else to adopt an “agency” e-book pricing model where publishers, not retailers, set prices. Apple moved to further its own legitimate business goals, embracing an agency model that was already being mulled by Barnes & Noble and others. And publishers and retailers, and yes, even Amazon did just the same. Said Snyder, “Amazon changed its business model for prudent and intelligent business reasons.”
In short, the “where there’s smoke, there’s fire” prosecution the DOJ has been arguing the past few weeks is more theatrical smoke bomb than festering conflagration. And according to Snyder, accepting it as truth and ruling against Apple would be a decidedly bad move, sending a “a chilling and confounding effect not only on commerce, but through content markets across the country. … We submit a ruling against Apple on this record sets a dangerous precedent.”
The final slide in Snyder’s Keynote presentation: An iPad with the text “It’s time to close the book on this case.”
Hardly, the DOJ opined in closing arguments of its own, asserting as it has throughout the case that Apple conspired with a cabal of publishers to raise mainstream e-book pricing well above the $9.99 price point Amazon had established, thereby harming consumers. “This is an old-fashioned, straightforward price-fixing agreement,” said DOJ prosecutor Mark Ryan.
U.S. District Judge Denise Cote is expected to hand down a decision in the case in a few weeks.
PREVIOUSLY:
- Apple Doesn’t Want to Pay the Feds’ E-Book Lawyer $70,000 a Week
- Apple Files Expected Appeal of E-Book Injunction
- Apple’s E-Book Punishment Court Order is Final, and Not as Bad as Apple Feared
- The Incredible Shrinking Apple E-Book Remedy
- Apple Says DOJ’s E-Book Remedies Are Biased in Amazon’s Favor
- DOJ Softens Proposed Apple Ebook Injunctions, Slightly
- Apple Slams Feds’ Proposed E-Book Remedies as a “Draconian and Punitive Intrusion”
- Apple’s Chances for an E-Book Ruling Appeal Are Lousy, Say Legal Scholars
- Apple E-Books Ruling Won’t Do Much For Consumers
- Apple Loses E-Book Antitrust Trial
- Here’s Apple’s Closing Slide Deck in E-Book Case, and the DOJ’s, Too
- Apple: It’s Time to Close the Book on DOJ’s E-Book Case
- Steve Jobs, Winnie the Pooh and the iBook Launch
- The Apple iBooks Origin Story
- Apple’s Cue Says Publishers Pushed for Higher E-Book Prices
- DOJ Misfires on Jobs Email in Apple E-Book Case — It Was a Discarded Draft
- Is Steve Jobs Message a Smoking Gun in Apple E-Book Case?
- Amazon Demanded Same Terms From Publishers For Which Apple is Now On Trial
- Apple Says Differences in Publisher Deals Belie E-Book Conspiracy Charges
- Apple Accuses DOJ of Unfairly Twisting Steve Jobs’s Words
- Apple Says DOJ Is Trying to “Reverse Engineer a Conspiracy” in E-Books Case
- Here’s the DOJ’s E-Book-Pricing Case Against Apple (Slide Deck)
- Apple CEO Tim Cook: “The E-Book Case to Me Is Bizarre”
- Judge in E-Book Pricing Case Thinks Apple’s Going Down; Apple Begs to Differ
- Here’s That Steve Jobs E-Book Email to James Murdoch
- Apple’s E-Book Argument: Deals With Publishers Improved Competition
- DOJ Filing Calls Apple “Ringmaster” of E-Book Pricing Rise
- Apple Alone Fighting DOJ E-Book Suit After Macmillan Settlement
- Apple’s Cook Must Testify in E-Book Antitrust Suit