Fear the Kindle

It’s hard not to love Amazon’s (AMZN) new e-book reader. For starters, it’s gorgeous. Unlike its bulky predecessor, the redesigned $359 Kindle, which came out this week, is light, thin, and disappears in your hands. If you think there’s no way you could ever get used to curling up with an electronic reader, you haven’t given the Kindle a chance. Load up a good book and you’ll soon forget you’re reading plastic rather than paper. You’ll also wonder how you ever did without it. The Kindle makes buying, storing, and organizing your favorite books and magazines effortless. You can take your entire library with you wherever you go and switch from reading the latest New Yorker to the latest bestseller without rolling out of bed. In my few days using it, I was won over: The Kindle is the future of publishing.

And that’s what scares me. Amazon’s reader is a brilliant device that shanghais book buyers and the book industry into accepting a radically diminished marketplace for published works. If the Kindle succeeds on its current terms, and all signs suggest it’ll be a blockbuster (thanks Oprah!), Amazon will make a bundle. But everyone else with a stake in a vibrant book industry–authors, publishers, libraries, chain bookstores, indie bookstores, and, not least, readers–stands to lose out.

Read the rest of this post


comments so far. Add yours.

  • http://blog.macb.net Mac Beach

    I got a Kindle, I like the Kindle, but it is far from perfect. It doesn’t disappear in my hands, and it would be rather inconvenient if it did. If I “curled up with” a book, i.e. fell asleep on it, I’d not have to worry about waking up with a broken book.

    The book industry is going to be radically diminished by the fact that fewer people read (anything, not just books). With Kindle (and like devices) a publisher doesn’t have to make a guess about how many copies of a work will be purchased, nor does a work ever have to “go out of print”. Big advantages for everyone except the printing press owner (which people need to soon distinguish from “publisher”.)

    On the other hand the Kindle doesn’t make it easy to organize your books (unless you only have 8 of them). It needs some sort of folder/tagging mechanism to categorize things so you don’t have to scroll through a seemingly endless list.

    I don’t like the DRM aspects, but that just serves to hurt Amazons business as I’ll mostly purchase things (subscriptions) and avail myself of free content to avoid the issue.

    Once there are a variety of similar devices in wide use it would be nice for a standard to be developed that allows a copyrighted work to be purchased once and travel from one device to another (same owner). I suggest the geerheads start working on such a thing now.

About Voices

This is a section of the AllThingsD Web site featuring posts that have been curated from around the Web: pieces we’ve read, discussions we’ve followed, stuff we like. Five posts are included here each weekday, but only the headline and the first two sentences. We link to the original site for the rest. The section is explicitly labeled, so it’s clear that content comes “from other Web sites.”

We also solicit original full-length posts and accept some unsolicited submissions. Voices is edited by Beth Callaghan.

Dive Into Media

Latest Video

View all videos »

Search »