Walt Mossberg

Recent Columns by Walt Mossberg

Mossberg’s Mailbox

Questions About Apple’s iPhone

There’s no other major item most of us own that is as confusing, unpredictable and unreliable as our personal computers. Everybody has questions about them, and we aim to help.

This week, I was swamped with questions about Apple’s hot new iPhone, so this is a special all-iPhone edition of Mossberg’s Mailbox.


Can you physically remove the included AT&T SIM card from the iPhone and replace it with another AT&T card or one from another wireless carrier?

Yes, and no. The SIM card, which carries the iPhone’s account information, can be removed by inserting a paper clip into a tiny hole at the top of the phone. However, Apple says that if you replace the included card with one from another carrier, like T-Mobile in the U.S., or Orange in Europe, the phone won’t work. According to Apple, some non-iPhone AT&T cards may work, but some may not.

iPhone

It’s possible that hackers will figure out a way to override this lock on other carriers’ SIM cards. But, as of now, the iPhone will work only with AT&T. Even overseas, at least until Apple does deals with foreign partners, you won’t be able to use SIM cards from other carriers. The iPhone will work overseas, but you will have to roam with AT&T and pay high charges. For instance, according to an AT&T spokesman, if you make a call in Europe, it would cost $1.29 a minute. It would cost 99 cents a minute if you are on one of AT&T’s $5.99 per month international plans.

Since the iPhone battery is sealed in and can’t be easily replaced by the user, what happens when it dies? Will you have to buy a new iPhone?

No, but you will have to send the phone to Apple, or drop it off at an Apple store, to have the battery replaced. The battery is covered during the phone’s one-year warranty period. After that, replacing the battery costs $79, plus $6.95 for shipping, and takes three business days. Details are at apple.com/support/iphone/service/battery/. Some small companies may eventually offer to do this for less, or in less time, as they have for the iPod.

One twist: because a phone is a necessity, Apple is offering loaner iPhones for $29 while your phone’s battery is being replaced, or for the period of any other repair on the iPhone. You will have to switch the AT&T SIM card from your own phone to the loaner, and then back again. Details are at apple.com/support/iphone/service/faq.

In addition, Apple warns that all the data on your iPhone will be wiped out during a battery replacement, but notes that it can easily be restored by simply syncing again with the iTunes software on your computer once you get it back with a fresh battery. That’s because, whenever you sync your iPhone with iTunes, it backs up the data on the phone. You can also use this method to fill your loaner iPhone with your own data.

Can I use the iPhone via a Bluetooth wireless connection in my car? Can I use Bluetooth to transfer files or other information between the iPhone and a computer?

In my two-week test of the iPhone, I succeeded in connecting it without much trouble to the built-in audio system and microphone on a friend’s BMW. Almost instantly, the over 700 contacts I had on my test iPhone were displayed on the car’s dashboard screen and calls could be made and received through the iPhone.

However, this first iPhone can use Bluetooth to connect only with cars and with wireless phone headsets. It cannot use Bluetooth to transfer any data to or from a computer, to play music through stereo wireless headsets, or for any other purpose. As with many other missing features, Apple has the ability to add these to the iPhone through software updates delivered by synchronizing with your computer.

If the iPhone’s Web browser is so good, why can’t it play video on Web sites I visit?

At launch, the iPhone version of the Safari browser is missing some plug-ins needed for playing common types of Web videos. The most important of these is the plug-in for Adobe’s Flash technology. Apple says it plans to add that plug-in through an early software update, which I am guessing will occur within the next couple of months. However, a separate program included on the iPhone can play a limited selection of videos from YouTube, and the phone can play videos you purchase from Apple’s iTunes store, and certain videos you create yourself.

You have been critical in the past of some smartphones that don’t allow you to delete emails with a single click. Can the iPhone do this?

Yes. If you are reading an email and want to delete it, you just tap on a trash can icon at the bottom of the screen and the message disappears into the trash can with an animation that resembles water being poured through a funnel.

However, in the iPhone email program’s list view, it takes two steps to delete an email. You have to swipe across the message header or preview with your finger, and then tap the red delete button that appears. You can also press an “Edit” button, which allows you to delete emails in the list view, but this still requires two taps per message.

Unlike on a BlackBerry or Treo, the iPhone doesn’t allow you to delete whole groups of email en masse by date, or even to select large groups and then delete them en masse. This would be a good feature for Apple to add down the line.

Can you buy an iPhone and just use it to play music and videos like an iPod, and to surf the Web or get email over Wi-Fi, without signing up for an AT&T service contract?

No. None of the iPhone’s functions, except calling 911, will work unless the phone is covered by a two-year AT&T service contract, and has been “activated” by AT&T. That will cost you $60 a month at a minimum. If you are thinking of buying an iPhone, you should plan on being an AT&T customer, and if AT&T coverage is poor where you live, work and travel frequently, I advise you NOT to buy an iPhone.

You and many others have criticized AT&T’s EDGE data network, which the iPhone uses, as slow. You have noted that AT&T has a much faster data network. Can the iPhone be upgraded to use that faster network?

No, it can’t. This first edition of the iPhone can’t use any cellular network faster than EDGE, which is much, much slower than the fastest cellphone data networks available from AT&T, Verizon or Sprint. It can, however, use very fast Wi-Fi wireless networks, when you are in range of them.

Apple hasn’t said anything about future iPhone models, but I fully expect a future model that can use these faster cellular networks, which are usually called 3G networks. So, if this is very important to you, I’d suggest waiting to see if such an iPhone emerges. But I don’t expect this to happen anytime soon.

In the past few days, AT&T seems to have tweaked its EDGE network, at least in some locations, so it runs faster than it has in the past. In my own speed tests, around Washington, D.C., I have seen repeated speeds of around 150 kilobits per second, roughly 50% better than the 100 kbps I have seen with EDGE in the past. However, I have also recorded speeds as slow as 82 kbps. And, even the new, faster speeds are way below those of the faster American cellular data networks, which can easily reach 500 to 800 kbps on a phone.

How good is the iPhone’s To-Do list or Task function?

Awful — in the sense that it doesn’t exist. The phone does have a calendar, of course, which syncs with the most popular calendar programs on Windows and Macintosh computers. And it has a Notepad, which doesn’t sync with any program on any computer (though you can email notes to yourself and others). But it has no To-Do list function at all.

Write to Walter S. Mossberg at mossberg@wsj.com


comments so far. Add yours.

  • http://allthingsd.com/ Michael Long

    I don’t expect a “to-do” list until Leopard ships in October, as you’re going to need something to sync to, and that functionality is only in the forthcoming Mail.app.

  • http://allthingsd.com/ Steve klein

    Michael Long’s comment about to-do lists is not correct. To-do is available today as a feature in Apple’s iCal. It’s listed right on the iCal web page:

    http://www.apple.com/macosx/features/ical/

    On Windows the iPhone syncs with Outlook, which also supports to-do lists.

  • http://allthingsd.com/ Keith solsun

    Michael, Since more than half of iPhone owners are Windows users, I don’t think that Leopard or Mail syncing together has anything to do with “to-do”s.”

  • http://allthingsd.com/ Erik Huddleston

    EDGE is certainly painful, and a bad compromise on Apple’s part, IMO. However, in my (almost full) week of web browsing with the iPhone, I have been very pleasantly surprised. I have found that the experience on the iPhone vs. my 3G enabled Windows Mobile device was comparable and in some cases better . (caveat, I use it mostly for interacting with web applications.) I wrote up my findings here:

    http://2glue.typepad.com/produ.....n-the.html

  • http://allthingsd.com/ Helge Grimm

    Michael may be right. While iCal does support to-do’s now, Apple will completely revamp to-do’s in Leopard. It’s certainly possible that Apple has decided to only support this new to-do system with the iPhone. After all, Leopard would have been released by now if it hadn’t been delayed.

    Keith correctly points out that the iPhone could still support Outlook to-dos for Windows users now. But that is a moot point because Apple would *never* include features in any of its products that would work with Windows but not with Macs.

  • http://www.dodd.org/blog/ Weldon Dodd

    http://www.tadalist.com works great on the iPhone. It does require an internet connection (between Edge and WiFi, I’m always connected), but it does provide extra functionality in that your lists are available from any computer and can be shared with family (honey-do’s) or co-workers. There’s a special view for the iPhone that works great with the Safari browser.

  • http://allthingsd.com/ Peter Lee

    Mosberg is not quite right when he says there’s no way to unlock the iPod and wi-fi features without signing up for phone service. There may not be officially sanctioned way to do it but workarounds have been developed in the form of software by Jon Lech Johansen (just do a google search to find his site) or by taking advantage of loopholes in the AT&T activation procedure. Instructions for the latter are available on The Unofficial Apple Weblog:

    http://www.tuaw.com/2007/07/02.....bled-ipod/

  • http://www.mitchcohen.com/ Mitch Cohen

    The iPhone plays most videos encoded in the H.264 standard. This is what I’ve been using on sites for the past year or so, because it’s a good standard. Much higher quality than Flash Video. Everything I’ve tested plays great, including very long-form video (3 hr+ town government meetings).

    Google Video does everything in H.264 – see http://www.engadget.com/2007/0.....o-as-well/ .

    Apple’s requirements and recommendations for iPhone videos are at http://developer.apple.com/iph.....ntent.html .

  • http://allthingsd.com/ Peter Lee

    my videopodcast:

    What is ludicrous is your suggestion that websites should change to fit the iPhone’s limited support of media formats rather than the other way around. The reality of the Internet is that many sites require Flash or Java to achieve the effect the site wishes. I don’t know where you are surfing but the web is media-rich now, it is not text-based and insisting the fault lies with sites that don’t offer the “Plain Vanilla” option is sticking your head in the sand. Absurd.

  • http://allthingsd.com/ Scott Smith

    Also make note that Acura’s 2007 TL will also import contacts instantly with iPhone which I was having difficulty with my Motorola or Treo Handsets.

  • http://www.mitchcohen.com/ Mitch Cohen

    The iPhone plays most videos encoded in the H.264 standard. This is what I’ve been using on sites for the past year or so, because it’s a good standard. Much higher quality than Flash Video. Everything I’ve tested plays great, including 3+ hr local government meetings.

    Google Video does nearly everything everything in H.264 – see http://www.engadget.com/2007/0.....o-as-well/ .

    Apple’s requirements and recommendations for iPhone videos are at http://developer.apple.com/iph.....ntent.html .

  • http://allthingsd.com/ Peter Howson

    What is the point of using the iPhone with another carrier? For me one of the huge selling points was the visual voice mail and having used it I can’t imagine giving it up. Can you still use the visual voicemail with another carrier?

  • http://allthingsd.com/ Troy Allen

    I would love to have flash on my iPhone. Multimedia websites like http://www.stickam.com need the flash player to view people’s cams.

  • http://allthingsd.com/ Ole Jacobsen

    Note that US carriers are planning to (or are already offering) 3G services on their existing 1900Mhz networks, but the rest of the world uses 2100Mhz UMTS 3G which the iPhone does not support. Thus an iPhone will not work in Japan, but several other phones on the market will (and you can roam in Japan on both the DoCoMo and Softbank 3G networks if you are an AT&T customer). Why Apple left out this band is simply beyond me.

  • http://allthingsd.com/ Roger Savain

    The restriction on the Bluetooth is devastating.

    In my Lexus ES350 I will not be able to tranfer my address book as I was able to with my Blackberry.

    What a Bummer!!!!

  • http://allthingsd.com/ Paul Levinson

    The “debate” about whether web sites or iPhones should change to meet each other’s podcast and vidcas formats is moot – as is always the case with the evolution of media, both parts will stretch, and shift, and change until they work well together … http://paullevinson.blogspot.c.....rives.html

  • http://allthingsd.com/ Keith solsun

    I’m not so sure Walt is right about flash being included on a pending update.

    The reason there is no flash on iPhone is because AT&T could get their SMS gateway and voice services bypassed by an embedded flash app. Flash plug-in has the capability of sending voice/video/data so it’s banned. However much Apple may have liked to provide flash support, you can’t block people from spending more money on minutes and SMS messages.

  • http://www.propertylabs.com/ Scott Phillips

    It needs a full fledged task program…. I’ve been using http://www.iphoneditin.com with my wife for our grocery lists… works well on the iphone when you want someone to be able to add to the list form the web, but something built in would be nice for work….

  • http://allthingsd.com/ Shannon York

    I have yet to read or hear of an explanation as to why Apple selected AT&T as their mobile partner, when their service and coverage are at the BOTTOM of the lists from both Consumer Reports and JD Powers. What was Steve Jobs thinking? Why not go with a top-tier carrier for his break-through phone. For me, if it doesn’t work as a phone, then the rest is irrelevant. And, for me AT&T is not an option, as it lacks coverage in 4 of the 5 areas in the US that I travel to frequently, whereas T-Mobile and Verizon have excellent coverage in all of those areas. Did Apple simply ignore service issues and, therefore, demonstrate an arrogant disregard for us, the customers?

  • http://allthingsd.com/ Gary Visgaitis

    Bought an 8GB iPhone Friday and rushed it home to activate and sync music, photos, contacts, etc. with my 17-inch Powerbook. I could NOT! Why? Because a “double (computing) standard” exists that Apple supports. Apple gives no options to its legions of faithful customers to connect iPhone ONLY with the latest version of OSX Tiger? And at the same time Windows users can activate and sync iPhones with Windows 2000, XP and Vista? This “double standard” is nothing close to a fair and balanced standard. So, where is the social justice, Steve? I run 10.3.9 Panther for various reasons like legacy software and personal economics. Yet, here I am, the loyal supporter of Apple for decades with far less options than Windows users that typically don’t give a hoot. Not happy I activated my iPhone with my brother’s Windows machine either, while my Powerbook sat idle next door. Suggest in the strongest terms that Apple provide a patch to allow loyal Mac users everywhere the ability to use all releases of OSX with the iPhone. Please.

    My other suggestion is in regard to the “Recents” list in iPhone. It would be great if I could delete individual entries whether they are incoming or outgoing calls. My Razor allowed it, why can’t iPhone? Also, add a button for “calls dialed” to better manage and distinguish between calls received/answered and calls dialed. They all run together now.

    Regardless, the iPhone is simply astounding!!!

  • http://allthingsd.com/ Dee Drey

    I bought an iPhone a week ago and have a couple of questions or problems. When I try to look up a video on its built-in YouTube feature, it auto corrects the words automatically preventing me from using a word not in the dictionary. For example, I know that I can searc for the words “Woz and Apple” to get a video about the history of Apple computer and Steve Wozniak, but I cannot use those same keywords that I normally use on YouTube when on my regular PC. I cant find a place to turn off the auto-correct feature or customize it.

  • http://allthingsd.com/ Dee Drey

    It’s pretty nice having a camera on there (2MP), with the large screen, but the camera is very difficult to use one handed, due to the button being on the screen in a place not handy to hit with your finger, while holding the camera up to take a shot. Also there is not a way to zoom in before taking the shot, like a telephoto. Of course, you can zoom in after the shot is taken quite easily, but there are no cropping or editing features unfortunately. A quick crop would be nice at the least, so that the photos could be shown easily, without having to transfer them to a computer and back again to the iPhone. If the object is far away, this leaves you guessing if the item you wanted to capture was captured easily.

  • http://allthingsd.com/ Dee Drey

    An amazing feature I just found was that Google Maps uses a color-coded green, yellow and red line on freeways to show live traffic conditions. Very very helpful in Los Angeles commuting! It doesn’t seem to be a thing that you can turn on or off and it only shows some roads, not all as color coded.

    Overall, I am very pleased with my iPhone. I held off for about a year to upgrade waiting for it. I also needed an iPod, so if you need an iPod too, the iPhone makes very good sense. The large screen puts it in another league from about all other cell phones like the Treo 700p or w, with the smaller screens and tiny keyboard. When you touch the screen keyboard on the iPhone, the letters magnify so you can’t miss them when pressing them.

  • http://allthingsd.com/ Bill Alpert

    The seeming inablility to play streaming media from internet radio stations seems, to me, to be a notable shortcoming in the Iphone web experience.

  • Michael Drumm

    My company is considering using the iPhone as our official PDA, but I need to work out a few unknowns before we move ahead:

    1. What is the final word on it syncing with Outlook email, calendar and contacts?

    2. While we will allow users to store music on the device (at their expense), we want to be sure that when it syncs with Exchange Server, the music is not then transfered and stored on our server.

    Any help is appreciated.

  • pwerglide

    What do you use to open mail that requires Adobe programs since Adobe and Apple don't get along?

  • http://www.usedtransmission.org Used Transmission

    I’m not finished read this yet, but it’s so fabulous ‘n I’ll back again when I was finished my job :D

  • Anonymous

    Can you sort your favorites in alphabetical order?

Stashing Movies

February 22, 2012 at 6:02 pm PT

An iPhoto Slide Show on CD

February 08, 2012 at 6:01 pm PT

Sponsored Topic

Latest Video

View all videos »

Search »

Walt Mossberg’s Product Guides