Peter Kafka

Recent Posts by Peter Kafka

"The Social Network" Is Just as Brutal as Mark Zuckerberg Feared

It’s hard to feel sorry for a billionaire. But here I am, feeling bad for Mark Zuckerberg. If you see the “The Social Network” you’re probably going to feel bad for him, too.

I saw a screening of the movie last week, and can report back that it’s just as rough on the Facebook CEO as his people feared it would be.

Not because of scandalous scenes involving sex and drugs–there aren’t many of those, and they’re quite tame*. It’s because the film portrays him as an insecure jerk who screws over people and becomes a much-richer insecure jerk.

At the end of the movie, there’s a suggestion that Zuckerberg may not actually be a jerk–he may just be someone who acts like one. That’s about it when it comes to the upside of his character: He’s the bad guy in his own creation myth.

But I liked the movie a lot–I’ll see it again once it comes out in October. And given that you’re seeing these words, it’s a good bet that you will, too. If you like reading about start-ups and growth rates and valuation, then you’ll like seeing it on a big screen, right?

The best hope for Zuckerberg and his team is that the wider audience for this one could be relatively small.

The movie may not be accurate–it’s based largely on Ben Mezrich’s “The Accidental Billionaires,” which Mezrich admits has many doses of make-believe–but there is lots of inside tech/investing baseball here**, and it spends a lot of time in lawyers’ conference rooms. It’s a dark movie with a climax that hinges on stock dilution, and the only vampire to be seen is Justin Timberlake’s version of Sean Parker.

So that may be a hard sell for a really big audience, at least at first. But no matter how well it does, it’s the only version of Mark Zuckerberg that most people are going to know about, and it’s a terribly unflattering one.

If that doesn’t make you feel at least a twinge of sympathy for the guy, then I definitely don’t want to be your Facebook friend.

*Note for Henry Blodget and crew: The coke and boobs scene made it into the movie but the girls keep their bras on. There is also a scene involving a 12-foot bong, which Zuckerberg is not involved in, and another one involving two couples having bathroom sex. He is in that one.

**The movie is chock-full of real names that the start-up set will recognize, from Dustin Moskovitz to Peter Thiel, but there’s one glaring omission. Sequoia Capital and partner Mike Moritz, both singled out by name in a version of Aaron Sorkin’s script that surfaced last year, have been replaced with fictional entities in the final cut. Would love to know the backstory there….


comments so far. Add yours.

  • Anonymous

    You obviously know very little about movie marketing. I’ve seen the movie and the marketing materials and predict it will be a big hit and will be nominated for Best Picture.

  • http://twitter.com/apphacker App Hacker

    I don’t know, I don’t really have any inclination to see this movie. I know little about Zuckerberg, but what I do know doesn’t really make me interested to learn more about him, much less see a movie featuring him as the protagonist. It’s unusual, I like learning more about other CEO’s like Larry Ellison or Steve Jobs, etc. This guy just strikes me as a jerk who got lucky.

  • http://www.google.com/profiles/warunsl Varun

    You should probably watch “Pirates of the Silicon Valley” if you already haven’t. I wish more such films are made. Great fan of Steve Jobs!

  • Anonymous

    But Jobs comes off as an ass, and Gates is a much more sympathetic character. Either way though, great movie.

  • http://twitter.com/deadeyeinside Jeff Garra

    Facebook & Aaron Sorkin are both trash.

  • http://www.facebook.com/ChicagoJoey Joey Kaibelf Yokubaitis

    Yup, I bet Sorkin’s mountain of West Wing Emmys means jack next to your trolling.

  • http://twitter.com/IMAVEX IMAVEX

  • Anonymous

    I think the Radiohead covers on the soundtrack may be better than the movie…

  • Anonymous

    I think the Radiohead covers on the soundtrack may be better than the movie…

    But Sorkin is a great writer, so I’ll be seeing this. He and Oliver Stone evidently share a fondness for hallucinogenics, which may aide their creativity

  • http://www.facebook.com/FloydianJosh Josh Alexander

    Ironically to me, Zuckerberg sounds much more like Jobs than a person like Gates. Takes ideas already previously designed, market the crap out of it.. and boom… there ya go.

    A lot of people can play David Gilmour’s Comfortable Numb, only one person was able to “create it”

  • Anonymous

    Someone should do a movie about Google next.

  • Shadowlayer

    Great movie, but not exactly what I would recommend to a jobs fan

  • http://www.rottentomatoes.com/member/moviesonline free movies online

    Guys like Mark who are “rich” don’t have a large income, they have a large net wealth. You can only tax income not wealth. So if he holds millions of dollars worth of facebook stock you can’t tax that. He probably takes only a small income from the company to pay his expenses to keep his tax rate low.

  • http://twitter.com/ikertxu Iker

    Who the fck do you think paid for the movie production???? what you are talking about is a load of crap with no sense whatsoever.

  • http://twitter.com/MommyBlogExpert Janis Brett Elspas

    G8t review. Hard work and sometimes being brutal, unfortunately, is what makes people a success now a days. As a mommy blogger (and former hi tech PR executive) I look forward to seeing this movie for myself when it comes out on 10/1 . Social media is here to stay and thanks to people like Zuckerberg the Internet is busier than ever.

  • http://twitter.com/deadeyeinside Jeff Garra

    Wow, opinion = trolling? You sound like you have a vested interest in defending them.

  • http://twitter.com/twittamentary Twittamentary

    Good review, good enough movie. I just wish the movie was more focused about the interaction of Facebook and its users more than its creator or beginning. I don’t need a movie to know that reality. In fact, there’s this Twitter documentary that shows that reality, furthermore, the film will show the interaction of Twitter and its users in real-time.

  • http://twitter.com/kseawins Kacy Press

    Facebook creator, Mark Zuckerberg talks about the inaccuracies in ‘The Social Network’ here: http://bit.ly/b9BqwF

Latest Video

View all videos »

Search »

Twitter’s still in its honeymoon period, but that won’t last forever. At some point, it’s going to be less of a wunderkammer, and more of a regrettable necessity.

— Reuters finance blogger Felix Salmon, in an article entitled “Why Twitter will get more annoying”